The battle between Rogue Echo Rower and Concept 2 puts two rowing giants head-to-head: CrossFit Games’ official rower faces off against the world’s top-selling machine. The Concept2 RowErg has ruled the market at $999, and now the Rogue Echo Rower challenges that position with an $895 price tag.
These machines pack impressive specs. The Echo Rower supports up to 500 pounds and folds away easily. The Concept 2 shines with its advanced PM5 Performance Monitor and weighs just 57 pounds, while the Echo comes in heavier at 76.2 pounds. Each machine brings something special – the Echo’s 4.7″ LCD console comes loaded with 10 workout programs, and the Concept2 has proven itself in gyms worldwide.
This detailed comparison of Rogue Echo Rower vs Concept 2 will get into every aspect that matters. We’ll look at build quality, performance features, monitor capabilities and long-term durability. Our goal is to help you pick the perfect machine that matches your workout needs.
Rogue Echo Rower vs Concept 2: Key Specifications
The core specifications show how these premium rowing machines are different from each other. The Rogue Echo Rower and Concept2 RowErg each bring their own advantages at their price points.
Price and Value Proposition
The Rogue Echo Rower costs $895, which saves you money compared to the Concept2 RowErg at $999. On top of that, it comes with free shipping, making it an even better deal. Both machines give you 5-year frame warranties, though they cover components differently. The Echo protects moving parts and monitor for 2 years, which matches up well against Concept2’s standard coverage.
Size, Weight, and Build Quality
The Echo Rower spans 99 inches in length and 26 inches in width, just a bit bigger than the Concept2 at 96 inches long and 24 inches wide. Both machines are built tough, each in their own way. The Echo uses an aluminum frame that stays stable during hard workouts. The Concept2 mixes aluminum and steel parts, with aluminum front legs and steel rear legs in its basic setup.
Weight makes these machines stand apart. The Echo tips the scales at 76.2 pounds, which is a big deal as it means that it outweighs the Concept2’s 57-pound frame. Both machines stay rock-solid while you row. The Echo’s heavier build works great in gyms where lots of people use it all day.
Weight Capacity and User Height Limits
These rowing machines can handle serious weight – both support up to 500 pounds. They work for similar height ranges with small differences. The Echo Rower fits users with up to a 38-inch inseam, just like the Concept2’s basic setup.
The Concept2 gives you more options with its legs. You can pick standard legs with a 14-inch seat height or tall legs that put the seat 20 inches off the ground. This helps if you have mobility issues or need an easier way to get on and off.
Tall athletes can stretch out fully on both machines. The Concept2 even offers an extra-long monorail if your inseam is bigger than 38 inches. This lets really tall people maintain good form and get a full range of motion.
These specs show how each machine helps different users, though they take different paths to get there. The Echo focuses on tough construction and good value, while the Concept2 sticks to tested designs and gives you more ways to customize.
Design and Storage Solutions
Storage flexibility sets these two rowing machines apart. Each manufacturer takes a different path to space-saving design. Their storage solutions work well for home gyms and commercial facilities.
Rogue Echo Rower’s Folding Mechanism
The Echo Rower comes with a smart folding mechanism that cuts down its size substantially. Once folded, it takes up just 38 inches by 26 inches of floor space. The folding steps are simple – lift the lock latch marked “PULL” in the center, then use the “LIFT” mechanism.
The rower’s safety features include a sturdy latch system that locks it securely when opened. Its folded position keeps the base, flywheel, and wheels touching the floor for better weight distribution. The manufacturer warns users not to lean the folded unit against walls or objects to protect both the equipment and nearby surfaces.
Concept 2’s Two-Piece Breakdown System
Concept2 RowErg takes a different route with its quick-release framelock mechanism that splits the machine into two parts. You won’t need any tools for this. This design lets users store the pieces separately, which gives them more options for space management.
Taking it apart is straightforward and works great in places where you can’t leave it set up permanently. This feature helps gyms running group rowing classes and home users with tight spaces store it between workouts.
Transport Features: Turf Tires vs Standard Wheels
Both machines shine when it comes to mobility. The Echo Rower sports 8.5-inch diameter polyurethane turf tires that roll smoothly on any surface. These bigger wheels handle transitions between different flooring types and gym mats with ease.
The Concept2 comes with standard caster wheels on its front feet. These wheels do the job well, thanks to the machine’s lighter 57-pound frame. While it doesn’t have a dedicated back handle, the monorail’s design lets users lift and move the unit without trouble.
The Echo’s turf tires work together with a built-in handle at the footplate’s base to make moving easier. This setup really helps when you need to move the folded unit between storage and workout areas. The larger wheels solve a common issue with regular rowing machine wheels – they don’t get stuck on raised surfaces or gym flooring seams.
Each machine shows clever engineering in its storage design. The Echo’s single-unit folding system focuses on quick changes and compact storage, making it perfect for homes where space matters most. The Concept2’s two-piece breakdown offers flexible storage options but needs a bit more effort to set up and take apart.
Performance and Resistance Systems
The Rogue Echo Rower and Concept2 RowErg both use advanced air resistance technology that sets them apart from other rowing machines. These machines deliver dynamic workouts that adapt to how hard you work.
Air Resistance Mechanisms
Each machine has a flywheel at its heart, connected to the handle through a chain system. When you pull the handle, the flywheel spins and creates resistance by displacing air. The resistance naturally adjusts based on how hard you row – pull faster and you’ll feel more resistance, just like rowing on water.
You’ll notice the Echo Rower has a slightly heavier pull at first, which gives it a unique feel when you start each stroke. The Concept2, however, keeps the resistance more even throughout your rowing motion. Both machines give you smooth, fluid motions that are easy on your joints.
Damper Settings and Resistance Adjustment
Both machines come with damper settings from 1 to 10. Many people think these settings control resistance directly, but they don’t. They change how rowing feels, much like changing gears on a bicycle.
Rowing at lower settings (1-4) feels like you’re in a racing boat – you need quick, sharp pulls. Higher settings feel more like a heavy boat where you need more power through each stroke. Your workout intensity really depends on how much force you put into each pull with your legs, back, and arms.
The Echo Rower makes it easy to adjust resistance with its large, clear numbers and well-placed adjustment handle. You can quickly change settings between workout segments without stopping.
Stroke Feel and Smoothness
These machines feel remarkably alike when you row. The Echo Rower keeps the smooth feel that made the Concept2 so popular, with some nice refinements. These improvements show up most in how the stroke begins and transitions.
Both machines have features that help keep your stroke consistent:
- Their flywheels stay smooth while minimizing wear and tear
- The resistance matches your effort – less at slower speeds, more when you row faster
- Air resistance needs very little maintenance compared to other types
S-E-A, a third-party engineering firm, tested the Echo Rower to make sure it matched Concept2’s performance standards. Athletes can switch between these machines without changing their technique.
Both rowers work great for high-intensity interval training (HIIT) and CrossFit. You can switch between all-out effort and recovery without touching any settings. This makes them perfect for varied workout routines.
The machines do sound different when you use them. The air resistance makes a whooshing sound. Many users find this helpful for keeping their rhythm, though it’s louder than magnetic resistance systems.
Monitor Technology and Metrics
The display technology creates a significant difference between these premium rowing machines. Each manufacturer focuses on different aspects of performance tracking and connectivity.
Rogue’s LCD Console vs Concept2’s PM5
The Echo Rower comes with a 4.7-inch backlit LCD console that stays visible even when lights are dim. Two D-cell batteries power this self-powered display. The console has six navigation buttons – ‘select,’ ‘home,’ ‘units,’ ‘display,’ and up/down arrows that make menu navigation simple.
The Concept2’s PM5 monitor shows metrics on a 12-by-12-inch black-and-white screen. Athletes can start their workouts right away with the “Just Row” option or choose from pre-programmed routines. The PM5 lets users switch between display modes and shows specific metrics in larger fonts based on what they prefer.
Data Tracking Capabilities
The Echo Rower’s console tracks these simple performance metrics:
- Total meters rowed
- Split time (500m pace)
- Stroke rate (SPM)
- Watts output
- Calories burned
The Concept2’s PM5 tracks these simple metrics too but adds advanced features that analyze performance in detail. Rowing experts confirm the monitor’s accuracy. Users can adjust their display to focus on specific metrics during workouts.
App Connectivity and Third-Party Compatibility
Both machines shine with their connectivity options through different approaches. The Echo Rower supports Bluetooth and ANT+ protocols and works with many fitness devices. The console naturally connects with several third-party applications:
- ErgZone
- Regatta
- Peloton
- Other FTMS compatible apps
The Echo Rower works with all Garmin, Suunto, and ANT+ / Bluetooth heart rate monitors. A well-designed phone holder sits at the console’s top and fits devices up to 3.45 inches wide.
The Concept2’s PM5 uses an open platform architecture that works with many fitness applications. Workout data syncs automatically with various platforms:
- Strava
- Garmin Connect
- Training Peaks
- CrewLAB
- FitBit
- Final Surge
The PM5’s integration with ErgData stands out as a key advantage. This dedicated app provides complete workout statistics like:
- Strokes per minute
- Watts output
- Calories burned
- Total distance
- Total time
- Target splits
- Projected finish times
- Heart rate monitoring (with compatible devices)
The PM5 goes beyond simple tracking and lets users join worldwide leaderboards and virtual competitions. Athletes who want competitive standards or community engagement find this feature valuable.
Both machines store workout history on their consoles. The Echo Rower logs previous sessions, while the Concept2’s PM5 lets users export and analyze data for $19.99 per year.
Comfort and Ergonomics
These rowing machines stand out with their ergonomic design elements. Each manufacturer takes a different approach to make users comfortable. The Rogue Echo Rower and Concept2 RowErg come with unique features that boost the overall rowing experience.
Seat Design and Comfort
The Echo Rower comes with a polyurethane cushioned seat that matches the comfort level of Rogue’s premium bench lineup. This improved padding helps during long training sessions. The seat stays 16 inches above the floor, which ensures proper positioning as you row.
Concept2 RowErg’s seat can be set up in two different heights. The standard legs put the seat 14 inches from the ground, while taller legs lift it to 20 inches. This flexibility is great if you have mobility needs or want easier access to the machine.
Foot Straps and Quick-Release System
The Echo Rower’s patent-pending quick-release foot strap design is a standout feature. This innovative system lets you:
- Set your preferred strap tension faster
- Release straps using a side latch mechanism
- Switch between exercises quickly
CrossFit athletes love the quick-release mechanism because they often switch between different movements during workouts. The Echo’s wide, durable straps keep feet secure while staying easy to adjust.
Handle Design and Grip
Both machines excel in handle ergonomics through smart design choices. The Echo Rower’s slightly angled handle reduces wrist strain during long sessions. It feels familiar like traditional rowing handles but with subtle improvements for better comfort.
The handles feel slightly different on each machine. The Echo’s handle scores 9.0/10 for ergonomics and holds up well over time. The Concept2’s handle design serves as the industry standard, focusing on natural hand placement throughout each stroke.
The Echo Rower’s comfort ratings show its focus on user experience:
- Seat Comfort: 9.2/10
- Handle Ergonomics: 9.0/10
- Foot Strap Comfort: 9.5/10
These comfort features make each machine suitable in a variety of training environments. The Echo Rower’s improved padding, quick-release system, and ergonomic handle work great for high-intensity interval training. The Concept2’s proven design elements continue to support athletes of all skill levels, from beginners to competitive rowers.
[Related: Best Rowing Machines & Upright Rower Machines]
Durability and Maintenance Requirements
Reliability and maintenance are key factors that set these premium rowing machines apart. Let’s get into the differences in how they perform and what they need for upkeep over time.
Long-Term Reliability Assessment
The Concept2 RowErg shows remarkable toughness in commercial settings. Many units still work perfectly even after 20 years of constant use. High school rowing programs report these machines work reliably despite heavy daily use by multiple athletes. One user tracked consistent performance after rowing 1.5 million meters over nine years.
The Echo Rower, built to competition standards, earned a perfect 5-out-of-5 durability rating in extensive tests. Its heavy-duty aluminum frame, reinforced monorail, and strengthened welds went through one-million stroke tests. The company worked with S-E-A, a third-party engineering firm, to confirm its competition-readiness against the Concept2.
Replacement Parts Availability
Parts availability creates a clear difference between these machines. Concept2’s detailed spare parts catalog supports models from several decades ago. Users can buy any component at reasonable prices, which makes repairs economical. This wide parts network has helped build the machine’s reputation for lasting long.
The Echo Rower’s replacement parts system is still growing since it’s new to the market. The company covers the frame for five years and moving parts and monitor components for two years under warranty. Questions still remain about future component availability and repair costs.
Cleaning and Regular Maintenance Needs
These machines work best with regular care routines:
Daily Care Requirements:
- Clean high-contact surfaces after each use with non-acidic cleaners
- Keep the monorail and seat rollers free of debris
- Look for wear on power cords and connections
Monthly Maintenance Protocol:
- Tighten all assembled hardware
- Check the frame folding mechanism if you use it often
- Look for wear signs in the foot strap system
Concept2’s simple maintenance needs stand out. The machine just needs basic cleaning. Users keep their machines running even after millions of meters. The Echo Rower also focuses on easy maintenance, mainly needing attention to its folding mechanism and quick-release foot straps.
The Echo Rower’s folding clip mechanism needs special attention. Some users worried about this part’s durability early on. However, field tests show it performs well when users follow the right folding steps.
These machines last longer when you:
- Check nuts, bolts, and moving parts regularly
- Store them in dry places away from extreme temperatures
- Follow the manufacturer’s cleaning guidelines
- Fix unusual noises or resistance changes quickly
The Echo Rower’s aluminum parts need extra care to prevent moisture buildup, especially in garage settings. Concept2’s steel components also need regular checks for early wear or rust signs.
Comparison Table
|
Feature |
Rogue Echo Rower |
Concept2 RowErg |
|---|---|---|
| Price & Warranty | ||
| Price | $895 | $999 |
| Frame Warranty | 5 years | 5 years |
| Parts Warranty | 2 years | Standard coverage (duration not specified) |
| Physical Specifications | ||
| Length | 99 inches | 96 inches |
| Width | 26 inches | 24 inches |
| Weight | 76.2 pounds | 57 pounds |
| Weight Capacity | 500 pounds | 500 pounds |
| Maximum User Inseam | 38 inches | 38 inches (extra-long option available) |
| Storage & Transport | ||
| Storage Solution | Folding design (38″ x 26″) | Two-piece breakdown system |
| Wheels | 8.5-inch polyurethane turf tires | Standard caster wheels |
| Monitor Features | ||
| Display | 4.7″ LCD backlit console | PM5 monitor (12″ x 12″) |
| Power Source | Self-powered with D-cell backup | Not specified |
| Connectivity | Bluetooth and ANT+ | Bluetooth and ANT+ |
| App Compatibility | ErgZone, Regatta, Peloton | Strava, Garmin Connect, Training Peaks, CrewLAB, FitBit |
| Comfort Features | ||
| Seat Height | 16 inches | 14 inches (20″ option available) |
| Foot Straps | Patent-pending quick-release system | Standard straps |
| Handle Design | Angled design for wrist strain reduction | Traditional design |
| Construction | ||
| Frame Material | Aluminum | Aluminum and steel combination |
| Resistance Type | Air resistance | Air resistance |
| Damper Settings | 1-10 levels | 1-10 levels |
Final Verdict: Which Rower Wins?
Both the Rogue Echo Rower and Concept2 RowErg bring elite-level performance, durability, and versatility to the table. The right choice depends on your training needs and personal preferences.
Go for the Concept2 RowErg if you want a proven industry-standard machine with the best-in-class PM5 monitor, worldwide leaderboard integration, and lighter build for easy transport. It’s also the top choice for serious rowers and CrossFit athletes who prioritize precise data tracking and customization. Choose the Rogue Echo Rower if you value a heavier, ultra-stable frame, quick-release foot straps, and a lower price with free shipping. Its turf tires and folding design make it a great option for home gyms, and its ergonomic upgrades suit HIIT and CrossFit workouts.
Ultimately, both machines are built to last and deliver high-quality rowing experiences. Whether you’re chasing PRs, improving endurance, or training for competition, you can’t go wrong with either choice.